Who's Afraid of Chinese AI Models? US Should Legalize Distillation and Fair Use
Score
68提出了美国应对中国AI模型的立法新思路，信息增量显著。
观点清晰，引用多方来源，但缺少数据支撑和具体可行性分析。
对政策制定者和AI从业者有启发，但短期内难以落地。
讨论当前中美AI竞争热点，时效性强。
来源为知名分析师的博客，且有交叉引用，权威性较高。
Base 75.5 × T2 Source weight ×0.9 = 68
Curation line 70Below curation line
Why selected
Novel and forward-looking policy insight, yet lacks detailed implementation roadmap.
AI commentary
「What struck me about this piece is how it directly calls out the hypocrisy of US labs suing for copyright infringement while trying to restrict distillation. For readers following US-China AI competition, open source ecosystems, and AI copyright law, Thompson's proposal is worth pondering—though politically daunting, the direction may be correct.」
Quick overview
Ben Thompson proposes a bold policy: the US should pass a law making training data collection fair use and barring terms of service that forbid distillation, to help US open models compete with Chinese counterparts. He argues distillation is nearly impossible to stop, so the US should adopt a new copyright policy that indemnifies labs and lets their learnings fuel further innovation. Meanwhile, Alibaba's decision to release Qwen 3.8 Max as open weights may have been influenced by Xi Jinping's speech encouraging open source and collaboration.
- US should legislate training data as fair use and bar ToS restrictions on distillation.
- Distillation is effectively just querying the API and almost impossible to ban.
- Alibaba open-sourcing Qwen 3.8 Max may be influenced by Xi Jinping's speech.
Full text
Who’s Afraid of Chinese Models?
Interesting proposal from Ben Thompson that both addresses the hypocrisy of labs outlawing distillation against their models despite training on unlicensed data, and could help US open models compete more effectively with their Chinese counterparts:The U.S. should pass a law that (1) makes explicit that collecting data for training models is fair use, and (2) bars terms of service that forbid distillation, for U.S. companies at a minimum. Stopping distillation — which is literally just querying the API — is nearly impossible; the U.S. should go the other way and lean into a new copyright policy that both indemnifies the labs and also guarantees that what they learned fuels further innovation for everyone else.
Ben also theorizes that Alibaba's decision to release Qwen 3.8 Max as open weights - a reversal from their decision not to release Qwen 3.7 Max in May - may have been influenced by a recent speech by Xi Jinping, who said:
We should seize this rare, historic opportunity to encourage open source, openness, collaboration and sharing.
Via John Gruber
Tags: ai, generative-ai, llms, training-data, qwen, ai-ethics, ai-in-china
Related items
89
FeaturedOpenAI Research: AI Is Redefining Job Boundaries
OpenAI研究：AI正在重新定义工作边界
If you care about the real impact of AI on work, this research is a must-read. Instead of theory, it uses data to show how ChatGPT users expand their task scope, offering direct insights for HR, managers, and every professional looking to upgrade their skills.
87
FeaturedOpenAI CFO Shares Five Lessons for Building an AI-Native Finance Function
OpenAI CFO 分享构建 AI 原生财务职能的五大经验
As an editor, I find this article uniquely valuable because it comes from a finance chief at an AI leader, not an external consultancy, making it highly practical. I recommend it to finance digitalization leads, CFOs, and anyone interested in AI-driven transformation.
87
FeaturedScientific Computing in the Age of Agentic AI: OpenAI Releases New Field Report
智能体AI时代下的科学计算：OpenAI发布新领域报告
This report is one of the most practical analyses in the current AI agent wave, especially suitable for practitioners in computational biology and drug discovery. It answers the key question 'What can AI agents do besides writing code?' and directly demonstrates productivity gains in complex scientific computing.
87
FeaturedReal World VoiceEQ: Measuring the Human Quality of Voice AI
Real World VoiceEQ：量化语音AI的人类自然度
What's noteworthy is that this benchmark truly focuses on the soft metric of 'human-likeness', not traditional speech recognition rate or MOS scores. For teams working on speech synthesis, voice cloning, or voice interaction, this is a highly practical reference tool that quickly identifies model deficiencies in emotion, prosody, etc. However, language support is currently limited; looking forward to future expansion.
85
FeaturedOpenAI Introduces AI Age Scorecard: A New Way to Measure ROI
OpenAI 推出AI时代记分卡：衡量投资回报的新方法
This blog post hits a sore point in the current AI industry: how to quantify input-output. For enterprise decision-makers deploying or planning large-scale AI, it helps avoid herd mentality. My personal advice: try defining 'useful work' based on your own business scenario, and avoid designing metrics that are merely formality.
85
FeaturedHow to Manage AI Investments in the Agentic Era: Focus on Useful Work per Dollar and High-Value Workflows
代理时代如何管理AI投资：聚焦每美元有用功与高价值工作流
This article is especially important for enterprises scaling AI agents. It reminds us that focusing solely on falling API prices is a trap; what really matters is the return per unit of work. I recommend CTOs and CFOs read it together and establish quantitative evaluation mechanisms internally.
85
FeaturedDesigning Organisations That Can Keep Up With AI: Organisational Latency as the Biggest Barrier
设计能跟上AI的组织：组织延迟成为最大障碍
What makes this article truly worth following is that it raises a neglected bottleneck: no matter how strong the technology is, if the organisation can't keep up, it's useless. For CTOs, CIOs, and transformation leaders, this is a more important framework than tech selection.
84
FeaturedRuff v0.16.0 Released: Default Rules Jump from 59 to 413, CI Pipelines Need Attention
Ruff v0.16.0 发布：默认规则从59条激增至413条，CI工作流需关注
For Python developers, this is an unmissable update signal. The significant increase in Ruff's default rules means we can no longer ignore potential issues in our code, and AI fix tools can lower the upgrade cost. Notably, Astral (OpenAI) is deeply integrating AI coding capabilities with static analysis tools, which may become the norm in future engineering practices.